Court Rejects Claim that Expert Failed to Determine a Business Valuation

USA legal system conceptual series - Illinois

Payroll Services by Extra Help, Inc. and Teresa Katubig sued Kimberlyn Haag in an Illinois state court. They asked the court to determine the value of Haag’s 25{d61575bddc780c1d4ab39ab904bf25755f3b8d1434703a303cf443ba00f43fa4} shareholder interest in Payroll Services. Pursuant to the shareholder agreement, Haag retained an expert who offered an opinion about the fair market value of the shares. Payroll […]

Death Row Inmate Freed After Bite Mark Evidence Discredited

A Mississippi man that sat on death row for over a quarter of a century has been freed and exonerated after the bite mark evidence that was used to convict him was discredited. The Crime In 1992, 84-year-old Georgia Kemp was found dead in her home in Lowndes County, Mississippi. Her autopsy revealed that she […]

Court Denies Daubert Challenges to Expert Opinions About Asbestos Exposure in a Shipyard

John Wineland died from mesothelioma. Wineland’s personal representative sued Todd Shipyard and other defendants for negligently exposing Wineland to asbestos during Wineland’s service in the Navy. Todd Shipyard filed a Daubert motion to exclude the testimony of four expert witnesses. Recognizing that the shipyard’s arguments addressed questions of credibility that should be decided by a […]

New Paper Condemns Failure to Establish Reliable Error Rates in Forensic Science

Criminal Forensics, word cloud concept 11

“Junk science” has been the rallying cry of lobbyists for the insurance and pharmaceutical industries. The term has largely been used to condemn expert evidence offered by plaintiffs in civil suits. While the claims that plaintiffs base cases on “junk science” have been largely overblown — the claims are intended, after all, to minimize the […]

Expert Allowed to Testify About Standard of Care Despite His Belief that the Standard Is Mythical

Pamela Scholl underwent lumbar fusion surgery in Indiana. Scholl alleged that the surgeon, Dr. Mohammed Majd, placed a screw too close to an iliac artery, causing nerve damage. She later had a second corrective surgery. Scholl sued Dr. Majd for malpractice. Indiana law requires complaints of medical malpractice to be submitted to a medical review […]

Judge Rules Gender Equality Expert’s Opinion is Credible and Reliable

An Iowa federal judge has ruled that a gender equality expert’s opinion is both credible and reliable and has temporarily blocked the University of Iowa from cutting its women’s swimming and diving program. The Dispute On August 21, 2020, the University of Iowa announced its decision to eliminate women’s swimming and diving as a varsity […]

Illinois Supreme Court Permits Party to Redesignate a Controlled Expert as a Consulting Expert

The Supreme Court of Illinois recently reviewed a state appellate court decision that permitted a party to avoid disclosure of an expert report by redesignating the expert as a consulting expert rather than a testifying expert. The state supreme court affirmed the lower court’s decision. Facts of the Case Alexis Dameron sued Mercy Hospital and […]

Virginia Supreme Court Allows in Evidence of Expert’s History of Testifying as an Expert

Election Experts Testify in Virginia Voter ID Case

The Supreme Court of Virginia has ruled that evidence of an expert witness’ past testimony as an expert is admissible evidence. The Accident In December 2015, Deborah Graves was driving her vehicle when she was hit from behind by Samantha Shoemaker. Graves experienced back, hip, and neck pain, along with increased depression and anxiety in […]

Expert Witnesses Have Failed to Offer Convincing Opinions in Support of 2020 Election Challenges

Challenges to the 2020 presidential election have been based on a variety of legal claims. Some lawsuits have argued that states followed incorrect election procedures or that state legislatures failed to authorize changes that permitted voters to cast ballots more easily and safely during the pandemic. Others have alleged that ballots or counting procedures were […]

Doctors Sued for Malpractice Must Use Expert Witness to Prove that a Different Doctor’s Negligence Caused the Patients Injury

The injury victim in a medical malpractice lawsuit is nearly always required to present expert testimony to establish that a physician breached the applicable standard of care and that the breach caused the victim’s injury. The Maryland Court of Appeals was asked whether the same standard applies to a doctor who defends a malpractice claim […]

ExpertPages Blog